How to compare two startup job offers

A structured way to compare two startup offers without letting brand name, headline salary or speculative equity dominate the decision.

PUBLISHED 09/10/20262 MIN READ

Two startup offers can be difficult to compare because the differences are rarely only salary.

Build a decision table before relying on instinct.

1. Cash compensation

Compare:

  • base salary
  • bonus or commission
  • guaranteed allowances
  • employer pension

Use guaranteed cash separately from variable pay.

2. Equity

Record the actual terms you know:

  • scheme
  • number of options or shares
  • exercise price
  • vesting
  • exercise rules
  • leaver rules
  • liquidity history

Do not convert the grant into guaranteed annual income.

3. Role quality

Ask:

  • What will I own?
  • Who sets priorities?
  • What does success look like?
  • Is the title consistent with the responsibility?
  • Will I learn something I want to learn?

4. Manager

Your manager can matter as much as the company name.

Compare:

  • clarity
  • feedback
  • experience
  • trust
  • how they handled disagreement in interview

5. Company

Compare:

  • business model
  • stage
  • current growth and hiring
  • funding or profitability context
  • major risks
  • whether leadership answers questions clearly

6. Working life

Include:

  • office days
  • commute
  • hours
  • holiday
  • flexibility
  • travel
  • team location

A role that pays more can still leave you with less usable time or higher costs.

7. Downside

Ask:

If the company fails or the job is wrong in 12 months, what will I still have gained?

A strong answer might be:

  • a new skill
  • better title or scope
  • valuable domain experience
  • stronger network
  • demonstrable work

Score only after writing

You can weight each category from 1–5 if that helps.

The point is not to turn your career into a spreadsheet. It is to stop one emotionally loud factor from hiding the rest of the decision.

Compare live jobs