Salary vs equity: how to compare a startup offer

Do not add speculative option value to salary. Compare cash, benefits and equity separately, then decide how much uncertainty you can afford.

PUBLISHED 09/10/20263 MIN READ

A startup may frame compensation as a trade-off between cash today and ownership that could be valuable later.

The mistake is turning an uncertain option grant into a guaranteed salary equivalent.

Compare cash first

Write down:

  • base salary
  • bonus or commission
  • employer pension
  • holiday
  • major benefits
  • travel or office costs created by the work pattern

Ask whether the cash package works for your life without assuming the equity pays out.

Put equity in a separate column

For options, record:

  • scheme type
  • number of options
  • percentage represented, if the company provides it
  • exercise price
  • vesting
  • cliff
  • exercise conditions
  • leaver terms
  • expiry
  • any known employee liquidity history

If you do not understand one of those, ask.

Why valuation is not enough

A private company's funding valuation does not mean employees can sell shares at that price.

The company may later raise at a different valuation, issue more shares, be acquired, list, remain private for years or fail.

That is why the useful question is not:

“These options are worth £40,000, right?”

It is:

“What has to happen before I can turn these options into money, and what could prevent that?”

An illustration of dilution

This example uses invented numbers and a simplified view. Options are a right to buy shares, not shares you own yet. Suppose the company has 1,000,000 shares counting every issued share and every option as if exercised, and your options cover 10,000 of them. That is 1%. If a later funding round creates 250,000 new shares, the total becomes 1,250,000 and the same 10,000 options cover 0.8%.

Your number of options has not changed, but your percentage has fallen. Real companies also have vesting, exercise prices and other options, so ask for the figures that apply to your offer. This is called dilution and is a normal part of raising money. What matters is whether the company's value grows by more than your share shrinks, which nobody can promise.

Think about concentration

Your salary already depends on the company continuing to employ you.

If a large part of your wealth also depends on the same company succeeding, your financial exposure becomes more concentrated.

That does not make equity bad. It means you should recognise the risk.

When lower cash might make sense

You may rationally accept lower cash if:

  • the role is unusually good for your career
  • you strongly believe in the business
  • the option terms are attractive
  • you have enough financial buffer
  • the difference from market cash compensation is manageable

But equity should not be used to pressure you into a salary you cannot afford.

A simple comparison

Create one row per offer:

Cash | pension/benefits | equity terms | role scope | manager | company risk | work pattern

Then compare.

The “best” package is the one whose total trade-offs suit you, not necessarily the one with the biggest theoretical upside.

Important: This guide is general information, not personal legal, tax or financial advice. Rules and individual circumstances can change; check current official guidance and take professional advice where appropriate.

Compare live roles